This is where I will take notes on what I am reading. May be a daily thing, or just haphazard thoughts and summaries. Spoilers will be in here.
Further information on the books themselves can be found at the Book List.
January 14th, 2026 |
Lee Harvey Oswald in Black and White | I finished the book, pretty much. There’s an appendix with some documents I’ll get to. There’s not a lot to add as everything is too muddles to get anything out of it. Maybe that’s the point. There’s a strange letter he forged, or somebody forged, saying he was moving to San Diego and had to drop out of school. Yet he returned to school a year later. It seems more credible he was at school in New Orleans while Harvey was in school in Fort Worth. At some point, the “official” addresses switch from Lee to Harvey. Harvey was not the “real” one. An interesting note is that John Hart Ely, who got all the information on Oswald’s pre-Marines life for the Warren Commission, had some of his information “adjusted” or “omitted”, while simultaneously praised for how good his information was. He was only 25, just interesting to note. The last thing is Oswald’s Marine application. He signed up in 1956 and you can see on the application is was originally typed “OSWALD, HARVEY LEE” before being whited-out and retyped. It says he’s 5’8” when his photo shows 5’9”. It also lists he was in Ft. Worth from like ’42 to ’52 when he definitely was in New Orleans for a few years. The book ends and a second volume should cover the Marines years. There is an appendix discussing the various heights of Oswald in the Warren Report, some 5’6”, 5’9”, 5’11”. I’m not sure if they’re counting possible fake Oswalds in the post-defection years. The last appendix is a bunch of official documents that say Harvey Lee Oswald in them, some have both Harvey Lee and Lee Harvey. These are government documents and other letters. I’m not sure how anyone could get his name wrong. Maybe in the first month after the assassination, but there are documents from the 70s with it wrong. One more thing, the authors about Robert Oswald. After his service, he moved to Fort Worth and lived with his mother for a bit until he got married. This would have been Harvey and false Marguerite. Robert was in on the scheme from the beginning, especially given the Bronx zoo photo, and took it to the grave. Did he have no sympathy for his brother, who we never see again, or this other kid Harvey? |
January 13th, 2026 |
Lee Harvey Oswald in Black and White | The book doesn’t cover a whole lot of new ground. There’s a lot of conflicting information and questions and not a lot of answers. Harvey may have attended two schools in Fort Worth, as some people remember him at Striping and 2220 Thomas Place, and some people remember him at Monig Jr. High. Someone mentioned he lived on Davenport, which oddly enough is where Robert will buy a house in 1957. Is this part of an intelligence property network? All the while, Lee is now attending Beauregard and living at 126 Exchange. I don’t know how they can get away with the two boys switching places at the same school. Did nobody notice? They even had a common friend, Ed Voebel. It was, allegedly, Ed who got help when Harvey was under the piano. Ed also befriended Lee, according to him, after some boys knocked his front tooth out (Lee had his teeth fixed in the marines, the Oswald corpse had all his natural teeth). Ed would die suspiciously at age 31. Did Ed not put two and two together, or was he hiding what he knew? We’ll never know. The last bit covered was about Oswald’s employment and, as expected, it’s all over the place. I’m not even going to get into it, it’s so confusing |
January 12th, 2026 |
Lee Harvey Oswald in Black and White | I must’ve been a year off in the previous entry. Harvey was on Exchange Place in January 1954. Lee is supposed to have left New York in January 1954, live in an unknown location until May or June 1954 when they move to a Mary St. apartment owned by Marguerite’s friend something Evans. A letter to John Pic from Marguerite dated May 1954 implies they just got back. There is a mention in Lillian Murret’s testimony of another address that John Armstrong believed to be the Evans home address. Mrs. Evans said she thought Lee was in Texas for a bit before returning to New Orleans. These other addresses have been hidden from us, if they’re correct. It’s hard to know human error, even in FBI documents, from intentional manipulation. Sometimes I think when the FBI gets an address wrong, they are just being lazy and used 1963 locations. But you can’t tell. A side note on Lillian, her testimony is all over the place. She was lying every other sentence. There is evidence of her and her daughter going to an air force base on Bermuda, and Lillian went to Havana. That’s extremely odd. Then we have Mrs. Evans saying Lee lived on Mary Street until summer 1955, but it seems not to be true. Around October 1954, Marguruite’s letters to John start having a return address of Exchange Place. They must have moved there earlier, so why is Evans giving false information, off by half a year? The upstairs neighbor at Exchange Place said Harvey (she didn’t know his name) was a polite boy who held the door open. Evans said Lee hit his mother and would scream at her when food wasn’t ready for him. Evans didn’t recognize Marguerite on TV after the assassination, calling her “haggard” instead of the “beautiful” woman she remembered. Where did Harvey go after Exchange Place? The suggestion is back to Ft. Worth, at 2220 Arthur or something similar. A vice principal at Stripling Jr. High said he was told to get records on Oswald for the FBI after the assassination. Oswald attended less than a year, he remembered seeing. A girl, interviewed by Armstrong I think, also remembered Harvey and placed him at 2220, across the street from the school. Marguerite lived here before and will live here again in 1963. Something strange about that. One more aside about John Pic. On Thanksgiving 1962, the family went to Robert’s in Fort Worth. John Pic hadn’t seen Lee in 10 years, but he did not recognize the person claiming to be Lee (who used to be Harvey). He looked different, and that’s his own brother. Sure, you can change a lot from 13 to 23, but John said he was thin, gaunt, less hair, and didn’t have a “bullneck” like Lee did in the Marines. Can you lose a bullneck in 3 years, if ever? I noticed he didn’t mention a height difference, though. |
January 10th, 2026 |
Lee Harvey Oswald in Black and White | We discussed the frail Harvey being seen by Dr. Kurian. Soon after Lee is seen by another doctor who described a big healthy boy. There are all sorts of contradictions in this 1954 timeline where Harvey is in Youth House and Lee is out. It’s all muddled. One important thing to note is that Harvey and false Marguerite would soon escape from New York to North Dakota. This is mostly scrubbed from the record and alleged to never happened. However, there is a letter to LBJ from mother who remembered the boy her son knew. The son forgot until reminded by his mother, but he remembered a Harvey who read Marxist literature. This is the Oswald who would go to Moscow. When in Moscow he was interviewed by an American reporter and told her about discovering Das Kapital in North Dakota. The FBI published this as New Orleans, but the newspaper article still exists. The ND excursion may have been summer of ‘55. The date is important because Robert claimed he took Lee to the Bronx zoo when on leave in the summer of ‘55. John Pic did not recognize the boy in the Bronx zoo picture and said Robert was home around September or October ‘54. Robert is a liar, that’s for sure. Obviously the picture is of Harvey in early fall, as he is in ND in summer. Lee would eventually return to school and actually went but was still hounded by the truant offices. Then they would return to New Orleans, both Lee and Harvey, but the time and place is important. Harvey would go to 126 Exchange Place (Alley), a nasty part of town, in January. Lee would live with his mother’s friend around May or June. Lee is not supposed to move to Exchange Place until later that year. Robert spilled the beans accidentally and said Lee lived in Exchange Place when he should have still been in New York. John Armstrong interviewed a teacher who knew Oswald, who went by Harvey, and dropped him off at Exchange Place after a piano fell on him at school. |
January 9th, 2026 |
Lee Harvey Oswald in Black and White | There were conflicting records of Oswald and where he was at school in New Orleans. Somehow he was at two places at once. Now we have big contradictions in New York. The official story has Lee and his mom stay with John Pic for about a month, where Lee threatens Mrs. Pic with a knife. At the same time, Pic’s in-laws say there were there for a year and John testifies his wife was fond of Lee. They wanted to take him in. There is a lot of confusion of what school Lee attended and where they were located. Some of the addresses are not in the right place. Robert says Lee went to PS 44 in Manhattan, but that does exists in the Bronx. Then Oswald gets picked up for truancy. Again we have conflicting information. Dr. Kurian says he met with Oswald, who went by Harvey, was small and scrawny, at then end of March (’53 I think). The court records show Oswald being picked up in April. Lee was one of the tallest kids in his class, so he’d never be called scrawny. One report describes a schizo, the other an intelligent boy. Harvey’s report by his probation officer has his birthday wrong and lots of details. It has his father’s name wrong, says his mother married him when she married Ed Pic, and says she had 3 sons with Oswald. These are huge errors that the false Marguerite must not have known. Is it possible Marguerite and Lee are with John Pic, while fat Marguerite and Harvey are in the Bronx? What is the relationship between Lee and Harvey? |
January 8th, 2026 |
Ulysses | I dropped this book. It’s okay but it’s not interesting enough to be 700 pages long. I don’t have much time to read and I don’t want to force myself to read it for another month. |
| Lee Harvey Oswald in Black and White | A Christmas acquisition. I enjoyed his first book on the JFK assassination. This is part of a biography on Oswald. I’m already quite a ways in so let’s see what I recall. It starts out discussing his family. His mother Marguerite Claverie was previously married to an Ed Pic. She had a son named John Pic, but this relationship did not last. She became involved with Robert E. Lee Oswald (aka Lee Oswald) and they married and had a son Robert. A couple years later she became pregnant with Lee Harvey Oswald. Robert died of a heart attack about two months before she was born. Oswald is born October 1939, though there is no birth certificate. There is a some sort of testament of birth, made days later after the birth and is different. A quick jump to post assassination, Robert Oswald was quick to sell out his brother to the media and wrote a book about how messed up his brother was. John Pic would not and his testimony leaves some speculation about the two Oswald theory. Marguerite is clearly not a good mother. Though she has some money from life insurance and rental properties, she is always acting like she is poor. Multiple times she put her children in orphanages. At some point she meets Edwin Ekdahl and marries him. He was probably linked to intelligence through his job. The FBI was denied records on him. They or she and with Harvey possibly went to New York where she was part of the Navy WAVES program during the war. It would be here should would be linked to the intelligence community. She admitted herself that she worked on a Navy base in New Orleans on the phones. Other than that she had no training and worked in retail. There’s all sorts of confusion in regards to addresses. She somehow has money to buy and sell multiple properties. At some point Lee is sent to live with his aunt and cousins, whose names I forget. The one cousin may also have been in intelligence as she travelled to many different countries by herself, strange at that time for a woman. Marguerite get divorced and buys a home on the wrong side of the tracks. The boys describe it as a hard time. John Pic is asked to drop out of school to work. At 16 or so he goes off to join the Coast Guard. Robert soon follows with the Marines. Both are desperate to get away from their mother. Lee jumps around schools, though a census document calls him Harvey Oswald. At this time there appears to be a second Marguerite Oswald. She is a nurse, short and fat, with glasses, who looks nothing like the first Marguerite. People who know the original are shocked to see her on tv after the assassination. A neighbor in Texas knows the short fat one but does not recognize the other. This may be around 1951 since I think Lee was 12. Soon after this they move to New York City to stay with John Pic and his wife. There are stories of Lee being a bad kid. Also around this time, Robert is stationed in Florida at a CIA air field. Strange. I am only rambling because it's hard to remember all the details. | |
You can talk to me about books, if you want. Email
Updated 1/14/25